NSUN responds to the Milburn Review

The Milburn Review continues the Government’s lethal and unceasing attack against Disabled people and those with lived experience of mental ill–health, distress or trauma; making social security cuts in an attempt to scapegoat a community already on the sharp end of decades of austerity. 

The proposals — dressed up as being aimed at ‘helping’ young people who are not in education, employment, or training (NEET) into work — include the suggestion of an entirely new social security system for young Disabled people, removing access for those under 25 to the health element of Universal Credit (which provides support to those whose health conditions limit their ability to work), and to Personal Independent Payments (PIP), which help with the many extra costs that come with being Disabled or having a long–term health condition. Other new forms of payment with various names are proposed in replacement, but ultimately they aim to limit any extra payments to a much smaller number of people, with most people moving to the basic rate of Universal Credit for under–25s.

By proposing welfare cuts to people under the age of 25 in the disguise of employment reform — setting a precedent for an approach to ‘reform’ that will eventually affect Disabled people of all ages — the report chains the ‘value’ of Disabled people to their economic productivity, and proposes forcing them into work without genuine support or structural change. How will restricting young people’s access to welfare by dividing them into arbitrary categories remove disabling barriers to their participation in society?

Disabled people deserve to be able to live without financial precarity, regardless of their ability to work. The review proposes cuts to welfare in an attempt to free those “trapped in economic activity”, but makes no commitment to improve the Government’s notoriously precarious Access to Work Scheme, nor to improving the structural conditions of employment that make work inaccessible for some Disabled people, even if opportunities are available (which they are so often not, especially in the most deprived areas). The idea that all work is inherently good for your mental health — despite so many of us experiencing the exact opposite — is one we are growing impossibly tired of.

Paying organisations £5,000 to hire Disabled people under 25 will not ensure those workplaces are genuinely accessible or supportive. It will not enable those unable to enter work to pay their heating bill or afford groceries; it will not enable Disabled people to live. For those familiar with the deeply flawed and painfully punitive bureaucracy of welfare assessments, the introduction of an entirely new, untested system based on stricter conditionality — with little detail on who and with what training, will be making critical decisions about who is and isn’t well enough to work — will ring alarm bells.

Disabled people deserve support regardless of their capacity to work, and forcing young people into potentially inaccessible and inappropriate work without adequate support will not solve the economic crisis the Government has driven itself into. 

These proposals come after the Fonagy review conceded that there has been a population–wide increase in mental distress — especially significant among young people — that is seriously affecting their ability to participate in society; any additional cuts, or the introduction of yet more hurdles to support to stay financially afloat will exacerbate this crisis, not help solve it. 

Milburn has also acknowledged that his proposals will not be ‘pain free’. Why is it that big corporations never seem to be on the receiving end of ‘pain’ or ‘difficult decisions’? We should be asking who this cost–cutting, life–threatening exercise props up at a time when the UK is spending record–breaking amounts on defence and Big Tech firms are infiltrating our NHS.

The report’s proposals depend on the conditions of a society which does not exist. One that invests in accessible and supportive workplaces, meaningfully involves Disabled people in the policymaking processes which over and over again threaten their ability to live, and most importantly, has a genuine welfare state which supports and empowers its communities to thrive. 

Disabled people know what barriers are preventing them from participating in society and how the Government, employers and civil society can help to overcome them. Why not listen to them rather than making misguided cuts and introducing yet more conditionality into the welfare system?

It is important to remember that Milburn’s proposals are still just proposals. There is still time to fight this, and as ever Disabled people will come together to do so. We will not be divided by age, ‘productivity’, or a state which continues to oppress us. We will continue to campaign to remove age–based restrictions, fund welfare and value Disabled people for their lives, not their livelihoods.


To read more on the Milburn Review and its recommendations, take a look at Benefits and Work’s summary and Disabled People Against Cuts’ key points. If you would like to write to your MP about the proposals, Rachel Charlton-Dailey has created a template letter which you can access here.